Birdeye is a reputation dashboard sold to your client, and the agency still drafts every reply and fixes every listing by hand. Riley is a proof worker sold to the agency. It watches each client location, drafts the fix, acts in your tools once you approve, verifies it, and signs a receipt you hand the client every week.
Start freeBirdeye gives your client a dashboard of reviews and listings, then it is on the agency to read it and act. The replies, the listing fixes, the proof for the client, all of it is still hand work. Riley does that hand work for you. It drafts the reply, waits for your approval, makes the change, checks it landed, and signs a receipt your client can read. Here is the difference, line by line.
Keep Birdeye if your client wants a dashboard to look at. When the job is doing the replies, fixing the listings, and proving the work, that is the job Riley was built for.
Set Riley up around one client, approve the work, and watch the proof land. Nothing to run after setup.